Face Powder on a Shrinking Base, Changes Nothing
Allow me to push back a bit. One of the most common fundamental mistakes some political economy analysts make is following the natural order of things; they don’t deviate much from the mean. The first mistake is following government portals and public figures and being quick to interpret them as an economic boom. The second is trusting the market over the government. Still, in doing so, one misinterprets it as an economic bubble driven by external commodity price hikes that will soon burst, and one that is also subject to the resource curse. That notwithstanding, I suggest that what is happening describes a purely rent-seeking, extractive state that is manipulating both figures and the market to mask its shrinking fiscal base while subsidising its inner-circle syndicates.
Last week, on Friday 19 November, Finance Minister Mthuli Ncube unveiled the 2027 National Budget. It came with a package containing familiar revenue adjustments: the personal income tax-free threshold was raised from US$100 to US$150, the Intermediated Money Transfer Tax (IMTT) was reduced by 0.25%, customs duties on cellular phones and electric vehicles were slashed, and duty rebates and suspensions were introduced for fertiliser manufacturing and approved local motor vehicle assemblers. Pardon me for my scepticism, but I see this move as a defensive fiscal retreat that is designed to offer face powder relief to an already ugly and overburdened populace as they continue syphoning and institutionalising their opaque rent-seeking behaviour (this system is only designed for a few who are politically connected, gatekeepers and loyalists).
When you look at the raised tax-free threshold on personal income from $100 to $150, that $50 raise only means that an ordinary worker will be able to realistically take $10 to $12 each month, showing how the purported stimulus is just an inflationary measure coming in late, as the basic survival household basket is sitting at well above 250 dollars. Worse still, the majority of our people are surviving in the informal sector or scraping by on less than $3 a day, meaning a formal payroll tweak passes right over their heads without buying a single bucket of mealie meal or paying a clinic fee. You cannot put a plaster on a broken leg and call it surgery.
The same half-baked trick sits inside the IMTT cut. Industry and parliamentarians pleaded with Treasury to scrap that tax altogether or at least bring it down to 1%. Instead, Ncube threw them a bone of a quarter of a percentage point moving ZiG transfers from 1.5% to 1.25% and US dollar transfers from 2% to 1.75%, claiming the state is giving up around US$100 million in revenue. Yet real business in this country runs on the US dollar. Clipping 1.75% off every electronic USD transfer still bleeds thin retail margins dry, forcing shop owners to demand hard cash at the counter and pushing ordinary people to hide their dollars under mattresses instead of banking them. More so, look at who walks away with the real feast while workers are counting $10 coins.
The customs schedule tells a very different story about who this budget actually protects. Treasury has handed out duty rebates on fertiliser inputs and suspended customs duty on Semi Knocked Down vehicle kits across 31 categories, yet both breaks are restricted to “approved local assemblers” who meet “prescribed conditions”. Whenever tax relief depends on getting onto a ministry approval list instead of open market rules, genuine local manufacturing rarely happens. The connected firms that make the list simply bring in almost finished kits without paying import duty, bolt on a few parts here, and sell at protected local prices.
When I run these numbers through my KUVHURA political economy observatory, the telemetry points straight to high fiscal volatility (Phi = 31.6) paired with weak institutional execution (AL = 2.8). Because these tax changes roll out across different months between November and January, traders have plenty of time to adjust prices upward before any relief reaches consumers, while tax collectors look for new fees to make up for lost revenue. People will not start trusting the ZiG or putting their cash back into banks just because transfer charges dropped by a quarter of a per cent. Treasury should simply publish the names of the companies getting those customs waivers and stop taxing everyday transfers while public clinics have no medicine.
Comments
Post a Comment